Truth above all

Create your Newsoras account

Log in to Newsoras

Entertainment··4 min read·

Amanda Seyfried Recounts Risky Role in Holmes Documentary

The Oscar nominee says she joined the project without telling her agents and later confronted Elizabeth Holmes' partner on camera

Amanda Seyfried Recounts Risky Role in Holmes Documentary
Image: CaseyJNewell vía Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0) — by-sa
GO DEEPER WITH NEWSORAS

Understand this article deeper

A project she joined before anyone approved it

In a Rolling Stone conversation with directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, Amanda Seyfried said she started work on You Can See Everything before her representatives knew anything about it. She had not signed an agreement with her lawyer either. The film had already spent close to a month in theaters and was approaching $80 million in domestic ticket sales when the three spoke together for the first time in a spoiler-heavy interview.[S1]

Fielder said the notion of bringing Seyfried on board came up two years after he had finished shooting the beach-house material with Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans. He and Oppenheim weren't sure how to keep the project going, and they saw that Seyfried's Emmy-winning Holmes performance in Hulu's The Dropout still carried weight for those around Holmes, including her parents. Fielder added that Emma Stone passed along Seyfried's number, the two spoke by video for about 30 minutes, and all she consented to was showing up while the cameras were running.[S1]

Seyfried remembered the approach differently in tone but not in substance. When Stone passed along the contact, she wondered whether Fielder wanted to collaborate with her, noting that her sister and many others admire his work. She had seen only The Curse. Fielder told her he had roughly 90 minutes of footage for her to watch and discuss, and she assumed he simply wanted her perspective on playing Holmes and researching the character. After the call she said she was ready to help, persuaded by his energy, the time he had invested, and the fact that the project had been kept quiet.[S1]

No approval and a persistent sense of danger

The first material Seyfried shot consisted of her watching the footage Fielder had captured inside the beach house, which is how she enters the documentary at roughly its midpoint. She acknowledged that risk weighed on her, and she described telling her agent and lawyer only after the fact. Her lawyer, she said, then had to put a deal in place retroactively for her protection. At that stage, she added, nobody had yet discussed reenactments.[S1]

Fielder stressed that Seyfried's original commitment covered only watching the material and talking it through. When the conversations turned toward her playing Holmes again on camera, he said the directors deliberately withheld scripts and scene details because the format was documentary. He stated that Seyfried held no creative control and no approval rights over what was filmed. She confirmed that plainly and said the fear of damaging her career or becoming caught in a dispute with Evans stayed with her throughout.[S1]

Even so, Seyfried described the pull of the work as stronger than the worry. She compared the impulse to sitting in the front seat of a car and urging the driver forward, and she said she wanted to put her hand into the fire. The film's reception and her willingness to discuss it at length indicate she stands by the choice, though she has said she would not take on such a project again.[S1][S2]

The dinner with Billy Evans

After viewing the beach-house footage, Seyfried said her priority was to meet Evans. She described the urge as a search for answers about who was directing events, and she found his conduct in the recordings distasteful. She called herself a Billy detective, driven by strong negative impressions and a need to see the man in person. The encounter took place at his home and became one of the documentary's most memorable passages, with Evans criticizing her acting and the two arguing over her remarks about Charlie Kirk.[S1][S4]

Before that dinner, Seyfried met Holmes and Evans' children, and the moment was interrupted by a call from Holmes, who was in prison. Seyfried said the directors had not known the call would arrive then, and she noted that she was with the children and their dog when it came. She also rejected any suggestion that the voice on the line was not Holmes, pointing out that the film is a documentary.[S1]

Seyfried said her view of Evans worsened after they met. She argued that he had no cause to be as aggressive as he was, a word she chose as a diplomatic substitute, and she said his behavior was visibly unhinged. She insisted she did not want to provoke him but felt the gloves were off. Being disrespected in his own home, she said, made her argue back, because she believed her position was solid.[S1]

Sources: Variety · Theplaylist · Goldderby · Thewrap
Portrait of Oscar Wilde

Ask a Thinker about this article

GO DEEPER WITH NEWSORAS

Understand this article deeper

WHAT THEY'RE SAYING
  • I would say there was a lot of risk in the back of my head, and then when I told my agent and lawyer that I had already done it… Not the normal process
    Amanda SeyfriedActor and Oscar nomineevia Variety

    Seyfried explains that she committed to the documentary before her representatives had negotiated any agreement.

  • We had a 30-minute Zoom, and you were like, ‘Yeah, come over with cameras.’ We wanted to show you what became the first half of the film, and then we would talk about it. That’s all you agreed to.
    Nathan FielderCo-director of the documentaryvia Variety

    Fielder recalls the limited arrangement that brought Seyfried into the project before any scenes were planned.

Comments

You'll comment as Anonymous. to comment with your username.
0/1500

Insults, spam and personal data are moderated.

    Log in to Newsoras

    Topics
    Amanda SeyfriedYou Can See EverythingBilly EvansElizabeth Holmesdocumentary
    End of the story

    Still have a question?

    Write it and Newsoras AI answers with this story's context.

    Or hear from · Free, no card.

    About the author

    Editorial reviewer

    Adelo Vieira is part of the Newsoras editorial team and reviews stories before they go out.

    NEWSORAS Editorial

    We stand for deep, verifiable, multi-perspective journalism. Our systems combine human reportage from leading agencies with synthetic intelligence to expose structural drivers.

    Create your Newsoras account

    Your email and a password. No card.

    Your free account includes

    • 5 questions a month to Newsoras AI
    • 1 question a month to the thinker you choose
    • Plus one extra welcome question, to try a second one
    • Answers grounded in the article, with its sources

    At least 8 characters.

    Free forever. No credit card.

    Already have an account?