Awards groups reach different verdicts
The major awards organizations have finished weighing whether Amanda Seyfried can be nominated for her portrayal of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes in Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's documentary You Can See Everything, and their answers diverge. The Hollywood Reporter, citing its own reporting, says the Critics Choice Awards have declared her eligible in the best supporting actress field, while the Golden Globe, BAFTA and Actor awards have ruled her out. No performance in a documentary has ever drawn a nomination from a major awards group, and until now many people doubted it could happen at all.[S1][S5]
SAG-AFTRA, the union behind the Actor Awards, reportedly pressed A24 to lodge a formal appeal aimed at making Seyfried eligible, but people familiar with the situation say no such filing is planned. According to the same account, the studio has chosen to put its attention on the Academy Awards instead.[S1]
The Oscar path runs through the Actors Branch
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences closed its submission window on the day the report appeared, after which the executive committees of its branches start sifting through entries, with formal decisions expected in early December. The Hollywood Reporter writes that A24 has received assurances from representatives of the Actors Branch Executive Committee that there is no apparent reason Seyfried would be rejected.[S1]
The Academy's documentary feature rules allow films entered in that category to compete elsewhere provided they satisfy the relevant conditions, and its acting rules vest the Actors Branch Executive Committee with the authority and duty to settle any eligibility questions. That committee has previously cleared acting nominations in documentaries for performers who held on-screen credits, as Seyfried does, and it has little reason to deny its own members the chance to vote for her.[S1]
A documentary that became an event
You Can See Everything mixes conventional documentary methods with staged reenactments built around Seyfried. It holds a 96 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes, became only the fourth documentary to reach the top of the domestic box office, has taken in more than $80 million worldwide and remains in close to 2,500 theaters. Last Sunday it collected a sweep of prizes at the Critics Choice Documentary Awards.[S1]
Fielder and Oppenheim are in the United Kingdom running a series of post-screening question-and-answer sessions for Academy and British Academy members, one of them moderated by Olivia Wilde, with Richard Curtis, Cate Blanchett, Riz Ahmed, Barbara Broccoli and Alex Garland among those attending. Seyfried, who was nominated for an Oscar for 2020's Mank and came near another for 2025's The Testament of Ann Lee, says she is eager to work the campaign circuit for the performance and for a film that could also contend for best picture, a category no documentary has ever entered.[S1][S3][S6]
How the actress sees the work
Seyfried describes the reenactment sequences as genuinely difficult and says she never assumed they would bring her accolades, noting that she grasps the politics, luck and timing that shape awards outcomes. She is unsure the project fits neatly into the documentary label, calling it a genre-bending piece.[S1]
She recalls learning only hours before bedtime, while in Venice promoting another film, that the movie would screen at the Telluride Film Festival on Sept. 6, and waking to a flood of messages and industry chatter that convinced her it would become an event picture that lingers with viewers regardless of their verdict. She says a campaign demands time and energy and that she is entirely ready to give both.[S1]







