Moscow Reopens Its 2021 Playbook
Vladimir Putin has said he wants lasting peace for Ukraine, yet the Russian leader who ordered the full-scale invasion of his neighbour almost five years ago still refuses to endorse a comprehensive ceasefire. After talks in Moscow with US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, the Kremlin set out what it regards as the necessary foundation for peace: a new, durable framework of indivisible security. In plain terms, Moscow is seeking a rearrangement of Europe's security order that serves Russian interests.[S1]
At the centre of that push is the Kremlin's contested proposal from December 2021, the draft treaties with Washington and NATO. Those documents would have blocked the alliance's eastward growth by guaranteeing that Ukraine and Georgia could never join, and would also have withdrawn NATO military infrastructure from central and eastern European states that joined after the Soviet Union dissolved. Western leaders treated the package as an unacceptable ultimatum; two months later, Moscow launched its full-scale invasion, and the drafts were shelved. They are now back in circulation and being cited again by the Kremlin.[S1]
Yuri Ushakov, Putin's foreign policy aide, has hinted that Moscow intends to attach further conditions to its list of demands, citing Western attempts to deal Russia a strategic defeat. That does not mean Western governments will agree. Even so, the mere presence of European security questions in the Ukraine discussions is treated in Moscow as a win, with the newspaper Komsomolskaya Pravda arguing that Russian diplomats had already forced the West to think about security and now needed it to heed Russia's concerns about NATO enlargement.[S1]
Europe Warns of a Trap and Sits Outside the Room
Kaja Kallas, the EU's top diplomat, has described Russia's call for a new European security architecture as a trap intended to divert attention from a ceasefire. She argued that the order of the talks matters: securing a halt to the fighting should come first, a peace agreement second, and only after that could Europe's wider security arrangements be discussed.[S1]
Europe's difficulty is that it currently has no seat at the table, and Moscow has shown little appetite for giving it one, criticising European leaders for arming Kyiv and for their hard line on Russia. This week's peace talks in Abu Dhabi brought together Ukraine, Russia and the United States. After his Moscow discussions, Witkoff suggested Putin had accepted the principle of European representatives joining a later round, but on Friday the Kremlin signalled that no final decision had been made. Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said a decision on a wider format for dialogue on Ukraine would be possible once Moscow understood European intentions and readiness to help the peace process.[S1]
Leverage on Display Despite the Costs of War
Putin appeared uncompromising and self-assured in his talks with Witkoff and Kushner, and the circumstances help explain why. Washington is seeking a deal, European capitals are weighing contacts with him, and last month the leaders of Norway and Finland telephoned him. Next week, on the margins of the Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation summit in Shenzhen, China, he may hold separate meetings with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping; Russian media are already likening the trio to the wartime leaders who reorganised post-war Europe in 1945.[S1]
Yet the war has been costly for Russia. After nearly five years of fighting, its forces have sustained enormous battlefield losses, its economy is under growing strain, and Ukrainian drone strikes keep hitting Russian oil refineries, raising fears of fresh fuel shortages. None of this has so far persuaded the Kremlin leader to stop the war.[S1]







