Truth above all

Create your Newsoras account

Log in to Newsoras

World··2 min read·

Duterte Impeachment Trial Turns to Defense Witnesses

Senators clash with prosecutors over dinner bills, shoes and travel as Sara Duterte's trial enters its 43rd day

Duterte Impeachment Trial Turns to Defense Witnesses
Image: George Parilla vía Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0) — by
GO DEEPER WITH NEWSORAS

Understand this article deeper

Bank executive takes the stand for the defense

The Senate impeachment court resumed proceedings on Thursday in the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, with the defense calling Bank of the Philippine Islands Senior Vice President Atty. Paul Roderick Ysmael as its fifth witness. The session was carried in live updates by Inquirer, and Philstar.com and ABS-CBN also reported the day's hearing, which ABS-CBN described as Day 43 of the trial.[S1][S2][S3]

Defense witness Atty. Anel Martin Antero told the court earlier that day that the 11 guests at a Tokyo, Japan dinner had paid back Atty. Mans Carpio after his credit card was charged P200,000 for the meal. Prosecutors and defense lawyers then clashed over whether a witness could properly be asked about Metro Manila's minimum wage in connection with that dinner expense.[S1]

Prosecution lawyer Amando Virgil Ligutan pressed Antero on a P580,000 sum he was said to have gotten from Carpio in July 2020, an amount appearing in a covered transaction report filed with the Anti-Money Laundering Council. Antero replied that he had no recollection of receiving it. He further said he would not tell a lie on behalf of the vice president or her husband.[S1]

Senators push back on spending questions

Senator-judge Pia Cayetano raised an objection when prosecutors asked about Carpio's purchase of shoes for his son's basketball team, saying public officials should not be deterred from backing their children's sports activities. Questioning of defense witness Chadrin Parian also prompted her to voice worry over students' privacy, and she declared she would not conceal her distaste for how the prosecution was proceeding.[S1]

Parian testified that Carpio sponsored shoes for members of the Elite Philippines basketball team, explaining a P256,882.50 credit card charge at the Nike Pavilion in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. He said Carpio also bought shoes for parents and guardians of team members who traveled to Kuala Lumpur, noting that not every player came from a family with financial means, and that parents take turns sponsoring shoes.[S1]

Senator-judge Robin Padilla inquired of prosecutors whether the witnesses' journeys to China posed any difficulty, noting he too had been there. Prosecution counsel Rep. Terry Ridon answered that the travel itself was not the point, but rather whether the witnesses were being honest with the court. Padilla likewise took issue with prosecution lawyer Reynaldo Robles' stance that officials ought to live modestly, asking if legislators own luxury vehicles priced at P16 million to P22 million.[S1]

Procedural clashes and a courtroom visitor

Defense counsel Lindon Bacquel sought to have Ligutan's statement that the redirect examination gave no reason for recross struck from the record, describing it as an improper manifestation. The exchange came after Bacquel asked Antero whether he would lie for the vice president and her husband.[S1]

Outside the proceedings, a Sara Duterte impersonator known as Inday Tasha went to the Senate while the trial was under way, according to GMA Network.[S4]

Sources: Inquirer · Philstar · Abs-cbn · Gmanetwork
Portrait of Oscar Wilde

Ask a Thinker about this article

GO DEEPER WITH NEWSORAS

Understand this article deeper

WHAT THEY'RE SAYING
  • I will not hide my disdain. I will not. I cannot. I don’t even know where to begin.
    Pia CayetanoSenator-judgevia Inquirer

    Cayetano directed this at prosecution lawyer Reynaldo Robles after his recross examination of defense witness Chadrin Parian.

  • Siguro nasiyahan siya sa outcome na champion ang mga bata
    Chadrin ParianDefense witnessvia Inquirer

    Parian was describing why Carpio paid for the basketball team's shoes after the team won a championship.

Comments

You'll comment as Anonymous. to comment with your username.
0/1500

Insults, spam and personal data are moderated.

    Log in to Newsoras

    Topics
    Sara DuterteImpeachmentPhilippines SenateMans CarpioElite Philippines
    End of the story

    Still have a question?

    Write it and Newsoras AI answers with this story's context.

    Or hear from · Free, no card.

    About the author

    Editorial reviewer

    Adelo Vieira is part of the Newsoras editorial team and reviews stories before they go out.

    NEWSORAS Editorial

    We stand for deep, verifiable, multi-perspective journalism. Our systems combine human reportage from leading agencies with synthetic intelligence to expose structural drivers.

    Create your Newsoras account

    Your email and a password. No card.

    Your free account includes

    • 5 questions a month to Newsoras AI
    • 1 question a month to the thinker you choose
    • Plus one extra welcome question, to try a second one
    • Answers grounded in the article, with its sources

    At least 8 characters.

    Free forever. No credit card.

    Already have an account?