What the appeals court decided
The Second Chamber of Argentina's Federal Social Security Court has declared unconstitutional the pension mobility formula created by law 27.609, which set benefit increases from 2021 until the middle of 2024, during Alberto Fernández's presidency. The panel instead directed that the mechanism of law 27.426, enacted under Mauricio Macri, be used to recalculate the benefit. The ruling came in a suit filed against the ANSES pension administration by retiree Carmen Galletta and reverses a lower court decision that had turned down her claim.[S1][S3]
Judges Juan Alberto Fantini and Nora Carmen Dorado signed the decision. Under its terms, the claimant's benefit must be recomputed with the older scheme from January 2021 through June 2024 inclusive, and then linked to the monthly inflation-based adjustment introduced by decree 274/2024. The court also struck down the cap in article 9 of law 24.463 where it produces a reduction of 15% or more, and it accepted ANSES's statute-of-limitations objection, which narrows the period for which retroactive amounts can be claimed.[S1][S3]
Why the 2020 formula was rejected
In his reasoning, Fantini held that the formula approved in December 2020, which tied increases to wage growth and tax collection, contained no trigger clauses or minimum guarantees to cushion an inflation surge. Comparing March 2021 with March 2024, the panel found that accumulated mobility reached 553.55% while the consumer price index rose 1,129.07%, a real loss of purchasing power of 46.83%. The judges added that later increases indexed to inflation did not repair the damage because they were applied to a base that had already depreciated.[S1][S3]
Understand this article deeper
How the recalculation will work
To rebuild the benefit, the chamber chose to restore the law 27.426 formula, which combined each quarter a 70% share of inflation as measured by the consumer price index with a 30% share of wage variation as measured by the RIPTE index of registered workers' average taxable pay, on the grounds that Congress had already approved that standard. Amounts already paid as mobility increases, advances and extraordinary bonuses must be deducted to avoid duplication. The average monthly passive rate of the Central Bank will also apply.[S1][S3]
The final sum owed to the retiree still has to be fixed at the liquidation stage, when ANSES works out the differences. The judgment's effect is confined to the claimant's own file and does not amount to an automatic general increase, yet it consolidates a substantial precedent for the many pension cases now moving through the courts.[S1][S3]







