Ranking the Top 26 Playoff Players
The 2026 Major League Baseball playoffs have arrived, bringing high-stakes October baseball. To set the stage for the month-long drama that will decide the champion, we rank the top 26 players from the 12 teams in the postseason. The criteria emphasize excellence in the current season and whether that excellence appears sustainable in the near term, along with current value. Players whose cumulative statistics suffered due to early-season injuries but who are now healthy and in prime form are included despite those deficits. These rankings focus on who is primed and skilled enough to produce big numbers in October and possibly November.[S1]
Several elite performers from these 12 teams are absent because of current injuries. Most notably, Yankees slugger and back-to-back American League MVP Aaron Judge will not be ranked. Normally, he would be near the top, but he is on the injured list with a calf strain and may not play in the Yankees' Wild Card Series against the rival Red Sox. Consequently, Judge's spot in the rankings goes to someone else. With only 26 players chosen from the 12 best teams, the bar is high, and painful omissions were abundant.[S1]
Players Ranked 26 to 20
At No. 26 is Matt Olson of the Braves, who delivered a 40-homer season and another year of high-level durability. Olson has been one of the steadiest power producers in the game over the last decade, and his spot is much deserved. No. 25 is Willson Contreras of the Red Sox. The 34-year-old Contreras, now a first baseman, has put up a career year at the plate in his first season with the Red Sox. He leads the team in homers, has a high OBP, and boasts an OPS+ north of 150, making him a true middle-of-the-order force.[S1]
Logan Henderson of the Brewers ranks No. 24. Henderson spent most of the early weeks in Triple-A and then missed significant time with a back strain. Since early July, though, he has been a force in the Milwaukee rotation, thriving at run prevention and command and control across his 2026 starts. At age 24, there is more to come. No. 23 is Payton Tolle of the Red Sox. The affable rookie lefty has a strong body of work across 26 starts and enters the postseason on a roll. Since the start of August, Tolle has a 2.52 ERA and an even better FIP, striking out 31.8% of opposing batters. He is in ace form at the right time.[S1]
Seiya Suzuki of the Cubs is No. 22. A pending free agent, Suzuki picked an opportune time for a career year. He has topped 5.0 WAR for the first time in MLB and has thrived in the field and at the plate. Suzuki heads into the playoffs with 26 home runs and 81 walks. No. 21 is Ben Rice of the Yankees. Some of the shine has come off Rice in the second half, but overall he has put up a stellar season in 2026. The 27-year-old All-Star has mashed right-handed pitching and is third in the American League in home runs and 10th in times on base. Rice has been a vital presence in the Yankee lineup with Aaron Judge missing so much time.[S1]
Understand this article deeper
Zack Wheeler of the Phillies ranks No. 20. Wheeler, who has been an ace for years on Philly's watch, came up big in the must-win Game 162, which is what he has done all season. In 162 innings, he allowed 55 runs with 193 strikeouts and 47 walks. That is a heck of a season for a 36-year-old coming off surgery to correct thoracic outlet syndrome.[S1]
Players Ranked 19 to 12
Alex Bregman of the Cubs is No. 19. Laudably, Bregman made it back into the Cubs' lineup mere days after suffering facial fractures. Now he is set to resume being a quality hitter at the plate and in the field, a key part of the best team defense in all of baseball. This season, the veteran infielder boasts 26 homers and 75 walks. No. 18 is Kyle Schwarber of the Phillies. A full-time DH with a low batting average? That is one way to look at Schwarber. Another way is as the MLB home run leader who has drawn more than 100 walks on the season. It is the latter set of characteristics that matter more, so consider him one of the best take-and-rake hitters around.[S1]
Drew Rasmussen of the Rays ranks No. 17. The underrated and overlooked Rasmussen has been stellar in his age-30 campaign. He has set career-best marks in innings, strikeouts, ERA, FIP, and ERA+. He has been an ace in each of the last two seasons, and in 2026 he has been one of the best starting pitchers around. No. 16 is Parker Messick of the Guardians. The top rookie pitcher in all of baseball this season, Messick has been an essential presence for the AL Central champs. Across a hefty 186 ⅓ innings this season, Messick had an ERA of 2.56 with 193 strikeouts and a WAR of more than 6.0.[S1]
Michael Harris II of the Braves is No. 15. Harris, who is still just 25 years of age, has been a standout defensive center fielder this season. At the plate, he has also thrived, slugging .491 with 63 extra-base hits and good speed on the bases. No. 14 is Miguel Vargas of the White Sox. The prime mover for the upstart White Sox broke out in a big way this season. Across more than 700 plate appearances, the 26-year-old corner infielder surpassed 5.0 WAR and 100 walks while also smacking 33 homers and stealing 22 bases in 24 attempts.[S1]
Fernando Tatis Jr. of the Padres ranks No. 13. Tatis suffered some brutal luck on batted balls early in the season, but the quality of contact was always there. In the second half, the Padres' superstar has found his expected level in a major way, which means he is in peak form heading into the playoffs. No. 12 is Max Fried of the Yankees. We all think a lot of Fried as a pitcher, but is he still underrated? He boasts a stellar ERA+ of 142 for his career, and this season he has been…[S1]
